JHI Home
About Us
Research Communities
Fellowships & Calls for Funding
Working Groups
Humanities At UofT
Events and Exhibitions

Making Sense of Faultless Disagreement

Making Sense of Faultless Disagreement
170 St. George Street, JHB Room 100
Time: Apr 20th, 3:00 pm End: Apr 20th, 5:00 pm
Interest Categories: Philosophy (UTSC), Philosophy (UTM), Philosophy (FAS), 2000-
Talk by Crispin Wright (NYU)

The Department of Philosophy presents

Making Sense of Faultless Disagreement

One of the most natural and, at first blush, most important ‘folk’ anti-realist thoughts about certain areas of our thought and discourse—basic taste, for instance, or comedy, or perhaps (parts of) ethics—is that their lack of objectivity crystallises in the possibility of ‘faultless disagreements’: situations where one party accepts P and another something inconsistent with P and neither is guilty of any kind of mistake of substance or shortcoming of cognitive process, broadly understood. However on close inspection it proves very challenging to make coherent sense of the idea and it is fair to say that a majority of theorists, even those drawn to some form of anti-realism about some of the relevant range of discourses, have come to reject it as incoherent. There is one important exception to this in the contemporary literature: relativists, of various stripes, often hold it up as something of a coup for their view that it can make straightforward sense of faultless disagreement. The talk has three objectives: first, to clarify, in the form of a set of five constraints, what a relevant notion of faultless disagreement should involve if it is to do justice to the folk idea; second to argue in the light of these that  relativism, in any of a number of forms, does not do the business; third, to show how to do better.

(Reception to follow in JHB 417/418)

This event is free and open to all. Registration is not required. For more information, please contact the Department of Philosophy at 416-978-3311.

About JHI | Contact JHI | UofT | Follow us on Twitter twitter icon

Copyright © 2011-2014 University of Toronto. Jackman Humanities Institute. All Rights Reserved.
Tel: (416) 978-7415 Fax: (416) 946-7434, 170 St. George Street, Tenth Floor, Toronto, ON, Canada, M5R 2M8